I have spent a lot of time fighting the same sorts of thoughts re. answers/signs during meditative states. I find if I just let go of all that over-thinking, it works best. Now if I ask a question, I will make a mental note of the sensations, thoughts, feelings and impulses that come to mind but I don't let my brain take it any further than that. I write down all the info. gathered that way and then sit back and interpret it with an open mind. If I let my mind run with the info. and color the interpretation when I first get it, not only can I botch the interpretation totally but I can easily convince myself that I made it all up. I think the more experiences you have with the receipt of info. that can't be easily explained away as coincidence and the more times you have follow up confirmation from your guides or higher self, the less you will feel you may have forced the answers. There will probably still be cryptic answers or signs. But sometimes those unravel later down the road. Keeping a journal on the results of your meditation will allow you to understand that when it happens.
As an example of what I am talking about, when I first started doing shamanic journeys I doubted the images that appeared to me A LOT. I had several sessions where a bison would come come to dance (at the time I only had a rattle to work with) and it seemed significant like it wanted me to know something and I asked what I could do to honor him without getting a clear answer. At the same time I was skeptical that it wasn't mind just making up this bison and it was really frustrating not knowing why the bison was there. I was writing everything down in my journal though. Time went on and the bison showed less and less and finally was no longer coming. Life got busy as it does, and I rather forgot that the bison had even danced with me. But then it came time to get a hand drum a year or so later, and after much searching online for the right drum, I settled on buying a kit to string my own. The kits were really reasonably priced and bison was one of the choices for the hide. Most places only had deer or elk skin as choices. I ordered the bison on impulse and it wasn't until later on that I read back in my journal and remembered my dances with bison and struggle to understand what he wanted me to know. I believe he was telling me that I would honor him by getting a bison hide drum.
I never thought of myself as being so left-brained but I do find I really have to let it go and just be open to the experience and keep exercising that right-brain muscle by doing stuff, like singing, dancing, writing poetry, talking to the plants, and all those things that normally make me a feel a bit uncomfortable and a little crazy. You just have to let your hair down.
