On a more hands-on level, taking the "what resonates and why" - you've said that reading about Wicca gave you a "duh, this what you've been looking for" feeling. Wicca (and paganism in general) is very cyclical - what can you do to become more aware of the natural cycles around you? Day/night, sunrise/sunset, the moon waxing and waning, the seasons... Do you have a garden or a planter box where you can get involved with and nurture the birth/death/rebirth cycle on a small, hands-on scale? Just some thoughts on how to bring the awareness into your daily life, even if you're not sure yet about the more "complex" questions like rituals or Gods or Sabbats.